Tuesday, December 26, 2017

WHETHER AN OPERATIONAL CREDITOR HAS THE RIGHT TO ASSIGN THE DEBT DUE FROM A CORPORATE DEBTOR?


WHETHER AN OPERATIONAL CREDITOR HAS THE RIGHT TO ASSIGN THE DEBT DUE FROM A CORPORATE DEBTOR?

In

M/s. DF Deutsche Forfait AG and Anr. M/s. Uttam Galva Steels Limited:

FACTS OF THE CASE

M/s. Uttam Galva Steels Ltd. has been engaged in manufacturing of steel rolls and import business in relation to steel. At some time, the buyer had entered into a sales contract with AIC Handels GmBH (“AIC” or “the seller”) for supply of prime steel billets.
The contract between buyer and seller states that in case of any dispute, the arbitration shall be pursued in accordance with Swiss Rules of International Arbitration of the Swiss Chambers of Commerce.

Further, it was decided that AIC is entitled to pursue payment obligation of the buyer before any competent court where a specially abbreviated form of legal procedure exists.

Upon the execution of the shipment, Uttam Galva accepted the imports by the seller without any faults and also confirmed that the amount set out in invoice represents entire purchase price.

ASSIGNMENT OF THE DEBT BY AIC HANDELS GMBH


Assignment of Debt by an operational creditor under IBC 2016


Subsequently, AIC executed a discounting agreement with DF Deutsche For fait AG (“Deutsche”), thereby assigning the entire debt owed to it by Uttam Galva Steels Ltd.
Deutsche, in turn, subsequently assigned part of its debts to Misr Bank Europe GmBH (“Misr”) through another discounting agreement. 

A notification of the same was sent by Deutsche to Uttam; however, was not confirmed by Uttam. This is the precise reason that both Deutsche and Misr are the parties to the application.

CONTENTION BY UTTAM GALVA STEELS LTD.

CD argued that that the definition of “dispute” is inclusive; mere denial to the claim shall be understood as “dispute”.

UTTAM also argued that the same bench member had rejected the application by the operational creditor in the matter of M/s. Kirusa Software Pvt. Ltd v. M/s. Mobilox on the ground that reply to the notice shows existence of dispute.


WHETHER THE OPERATIONAL CREDITOR HAS THE RIGHT TO ASSIGN THE DEBT DUE FROM UTTAM?


Definition of  operational creditor under IBC 2016


The Tribunal was of the opinion  approval of the corporate debtor is not sought for in case if there is a discounting agreement and mere intimation bounds the corporate debtor to be liable towards the new assignee.

WHETHER THE APPLICATION CAN BE FILED UNDER THE INSOLVENCY AND BANKRUPTCY CODE, WHERE THE CONTRACT PROVIDES FOR JURISDICTION FOR ENGLISH LAWS?

OC cited the provision in the sales contract relating to the provision that AIC is entitled to pursue payment obligation of the buyer before any competent court where a specially abbreviated form of legal procedure exists.

 However, the Bench declared that the corporate debtors has been under disturbing situation as the corporate debtor is consistently incurring into losses with amounts aggregating more than INR 15 billion. The bench is of the view that if any further delay is made in accepting the application, it will become nothing but defeat the purpose and object of the IBC Code.

DECISION BY NATIONAL COMPANY LAW TRIBUNAL


The Bench held that legal assignees are very much entitled to initiate CIRP action u/s 9. There need not exist a separate contract between corporate debtor and the assignees of corporate debtor to make their stand true to the fact under Indian Law. Also, the bench felt of no need to have permission of corporate debtor granted to assign the debts to the applicant’s viz. Deutsche and Misr in this case. Hence, the applicants are eligible under Section 9 as Operational Creditors to initiate insolvency action against M/s. Uttam Galva Steels Ltd.

Saturday, December 9, 2017

FILING COMPLAINT BY A STAKEHOLDER WITH IBBI



FILING COMPLAINT BY A STAKEHOLDER WITH IBBI

Now , debtor, a creditor, a claimant, aservice provider, a resolution applicant and any other person having an interest in the insolvency, liquidation, voluntary liquidation, or bankruptcy transaction under the Code  can file a complaint with IBBI 

INSOLVENCY AND BANKRUPTCY BOARD OF INDIA NOTIFICATION

New Delhi, the 6th December, 2017
No. IBBI/2017-18/GN/REG/21.—In exercise of the powers conferred under sections 196, 217, read with section 240 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (31 of 2016), the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India hereby makes the following Regulations, namely :—

CHAPTER I

PRELIMINARY

1.       Short title, commencement and application.

(1)   These regulations may be called the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India                                                                                          (Grievance and Complaint Handling Procedure) Regulations, 2017.
(2)   These regulations shall come into force on the date of their publication in the Official Gazette.
(3)   These regulations shall apply to grievances and complaints against service providers.

2.       Definitions.

(1)    Unless the context otherwise requires-
(a)    “aggrieved” means a stakeholder who has filed a grievance with the Board on failing to get his grievance redressed from the concerned service provider;
(b)    “associated person” means a proprietor, partner, director, officer, or an employee of a service provider, a professional or a valuer engaged by a service provider or any other person acting for or on behalf of a service provider;
(c)     “Board” means the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India established under sub-section
(1)   of section 188 of the Code;
(d)    “Code” means the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (31 of 2016);
(e)     “complaint” means a written expression by a stakeholder alleging contravention of any provision of the Code or rules, regulations, or guidelines made thereunder or circulars or directions issued by the Board by a service provider or any of its associated persons and includes a complaint-cum-grievance;
(f)     “complaint-cum-grievance” means a complaint and grievance in the same matter.
(g)     “complainant” means a stakeholder who has filed a complaint or a complaint-cum-grievance with the Board;
(h)    “grievance” means a written expression by a stakeholder of his suffering on account of conduct of a service provider or its associated persons;
(i)      “service provider” means an insolvency professional agency, an insolvency professional, an insolvency professional entity or an information utility;
(j)      “stakeholder” means a debtor, a creditor, a claimant, a service provider, a resolution applicant and any other person having an interest in the insolvency, liquidation, voluntary liquidation, or bankruptcy transaction under the Code.
(2)    The words and expressions used and not defined in these regulations, but defined in the Code, shall have the same meaning as assigned to them in the Code.


Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016

CHAPTER II

FILING OF GRIEVANCE AND COMPLAINT

3.       Filing of grievance and complaint.

(1)    A stakeholder, who wishes to file a grievance, shall file it with the Board.
(2)    A grievance shall state:-

(i)                 details of identity of the aggrieved;
(ii)                details of identity of the service provider;
(iii)              details of the conduct of the service provider that has caused the suffering to the aggrieved;
(iv)              details of suffering, whether pecuniary or otherwise, the aggrieved has undergone;
(v)               how the conduct of the service provider has caused the suffering of the aggrieved;
(vi)              details of his efforts to get the grievance redressed from the service provider and why the response, if any, of the service provider is not satisfactory; and
(vii)            how the grievance may be redressed.
(3)    A stakeholder, who wishes to file a complaint, shall file it with the Board in Form A along with a demand draft for two thousand and five hundred rupees drawn in favour of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India payable at New Delhi or an online acknowledgement of two thousand and five hundred rupees paid to the credit of the Board towards fee.
(4)    A grievance or a complaint, as the case may be, shall be filed within forty-five days of the occurrence of the cause of action for the grievance or the complaint:
Provided that a grievance or a complaint may be filed after the aforesaid period, if there are sufficient reasons justifying the delay, but such period shall not exceed 30 days.
(5)    A grievance or a complaint shall be filed with the Board online:
Provided that a grievance or complaint shall be filed by mail at complaintsandgrievances@ibbi.gov.in or by post or hand delivery at the Office of the Board, until the Board provides a facility for online filing of grievances and complaints.

4.       Identity of the stakeholder.

(1)    A stakeholder filing a grievance, or a complaint shall disclose its identity in the grievance or the complaint, as the case may be, and also the identity of the authorised representative, who is authorised to file it.
(2)    A stakeholder filing a grievance or a complaint, as the case may be, may request the Board to keep its identity confidential and in that case the Board shall keep it confidential unless its disclosure is necessary for processing the grievance or complaint or under any law.

5.       Registration number.

(1)    Where the Board is in receipt of more than one grievance or more than one complaint in the same matter, it may club such grievances or such complaints together for their disposal.
(2)    The Board shall assign a unique registration number to every grievance and every complaint and communicate the said registration number to the aggrieved or the complainant within a week of its receipt.
(3)    The Board shall not take any cognizance of any anonymous grievance or complaint.

6.       Disposal of grievance.


CHAPTER III
DISPOSAL OF GRIEVANCE


(1)    The Board may seek additional information and records from the aggrieved and information and records from the concerned service provider to decide if the grievance requires any redress by the service provider.
(2)    The aggrieved and the service provider shall submit the information and records sought under sub- regulation (1) within fifteen days thereof.
(3)    The Board shall close the grievance within forty-five days of its receipt if it does not require any redress.
(4)    The Board shall direct the service provider to redress the grievance within forty-five days of its receipt if it requires any redress.

7.       Disposal of complaint.

CHAPTER IV
DISPOSAL OF COMPLAINT


(1)        The Board may seek additional information and records from the complainant and information and records from the concerned service provider to form a prima facie view whether the contravention alleged in the complaint is correct.
(2)        The complainant and the service provider shall submit the information and records sought under sub-regulation (1) within fifteen days thereof.
(3)        The Board shall form an opinion whether there exists a prima facie case within forty-five days of the receipt of the complaint.
(4)        The Board shall close the complaint where it is of the opinion under sub-regulation (3) that there does not exist a prima facie case and communicate the same to the complainant.
(5)        If the complainant is not satisfied with the decision of the Board under sub-regulation (4), he may request a review of such decision.
(6)        The Board shall dispose of the review under sub-regulation (5) within thirty days of the receipt of the request for review by an order with an opinion whether there exists a prima facie case.
(7)        Where the Board is of the opinion under this regulation that there exists a prima facie case, it may order an inspection under sub-regulation (3) of regulation 3, order an investigation under sub-regulation (2) of regulation 7 or issue a show cause notice under sub-regulation (2) of regulation 11 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (Inspection and Investigation) Regulations, 2017, as may be warranted.
(8)        Where the Board is of the opinion that the complaint is not frivolous, it shall refund the fee of two thousand five hundred rupees received under sub-regulation (3) of regulation 3.


Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016

CHAPTER V

STATISTICS
8.       The Board shall periodically disclose summary statistics about receipt and disposal of grievances and complaints on its web site.

Form A

[Under sub-regulation (3) of regulation (3) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (Grievance and Complaint Handling Procedure) Regulations, 2017]
Date ……….
To
Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (Write here the address of the Board)
Dear Madam / Sir,
Subject: Complaint against [name of the service provider / associated person]
I, hereby submit a complaint against [name of the service provider / associated person]. The details of the same are set out as under:

Sl. No.
Particulars
Description
1
Name of the complainant

2
Identity of the complainant
Aaadhar No / CIN
3
Name of the authorised representative, if complaint is filed on behalf of the complainant




 

4
Identity of the authorised representative
Aaadhar No.
5
Complete address for correspondence with complainant / authorised representative:
(Along with Email ID & Phone No.)

6
Name of the service provider / its associated persons complained against

7
Identity of the service provider
Aaadhar No / CIN (If known)
8
Complete address of the service provider (Along with Email ID & Phone No)

9
Details of the alleged contravention of any provision of the Code or rules, regulations, or guidelines made thereunder or circulars or directions issued by the Board by a service provider or its associated persons.
Please quote the exact section, sub-section, rules, regulation, or clause, as the case may be.
10
Details of alleged conduct or activity of the service provider or its associated persons, along with date and place of such conduct or activity, which contravenes the provision of the law.
Please narrate details.
11
Details of suffering, whether pecuniary or otherwise, the complainant has undergone.

12
How the conduct or activity of the service provider or its associated persons has caused the suffering of the complainant or to any other stakeholder.

13
Details of evidence in support of alleged contravention.

14
Does the complainant have a grievance? If so, how it may be redressed?

15
Is complaint being filed within forty-five days of the occurrence of the cause of action for the complaint?
If not explain the reasons for delay.

16
Whether the fee of Rs.2500 has been paid
Yes / No
17
The Bank account No. and details of the complainant to which the fee can be refunded

18
Whether the complainant wishes to keep its identity confidential
Yes / No.
19
List of documents attached in support of the complaint:
a.    Authorization, if it is filed by an authorised representative;
b.         Demand draft for Rs.2500 / Online acknowledgement of credit of Rs.2500 to the account of the Board;
c.
d.
.
.
m.
n.



20
Any other complaint.
details
in
support
of
the


Yours faithfully


Signature Name of the Complainant / Authorised Representative

Verification

I, ………………………………., the complainant / authorised representative of the complainant do hereby declare that what is stated above is true to the best of my knowledge and belief.

Verified today, the ……………………. day of ………………, 20xx, at ……………………